– Advertisement –
-
as Peers Profit From Oil Rally and Strengthen Balance Sheets
Oando Plc is behind Seplat Energy Plc and Aradel Holdings Plc on almost every measure of profit, leverage and liquidity, even though all three have gained from the same rise in crude prices.
Meanwhile interest on its debt turned an operating recovery into a pretax loss.
Oando had a loss before tax of N74.65 billion in the nine months to September, compared with a profit of N19.46 billion a year earlier, according to its unaudited interim statements.
Seplat made a pretax profit of N1.34 trillion, according to its third-quarter report, and Aradel made N764.7 billion, according to its results statement.
This analysis excludes profit after tax (PAT) as it doesn’t show the true financial position of a firm (Oando) that benefits from tax credits which are exceptional events and one-off events. In short, the company should be explaining to investors why it always benefits from exceptional gains.
Oando reported a profit after tax of N106.5 billion only because of an income tax credit of N181.1 billion. That credit included N254.4 billion of reversed earlier tax provisions. A year earlier, the company booked a similar credit of N181.8 billion.
Shareholders and investors pay attention to cost performance of companies as they prefer the ones who prioritize operating efficiency to those who burn their cash on acquisition that takes time to be profitable.
While Oando’s price to earnings ratio of 3.6 times means it is undervalued an entry point for value investors, its deteriorating liquidity position as well as weak balance sheet are spending a pre-dawn chill down the spine of investors.
Where the Gap Compared to Seplat and Aradel Comes From
Oando is not adhering to its cost optimisation initiatives across the enlarged asset base as total production cost or cost of sales is 93.71 percent of total sales, which leaves a gross margin of about 6%.
Seplat and Aradel Holdings, recorded cost of sales ratio of 57 percent and 57.89 percent respectively, meaning they kept roughly 42 to 43 kobo of gross profit from every naira of sales.
However, Oando’s production costs are not rising. Production operating costs fell 22% to $15.39 per barrel of oil equivalent, and gross profit rose almost sixfold to N174.5 billion.
The thin margin comes from Oando’s business mix. Trading and supply made up about N2.22 trillion of its N2.78 trillion revenue, and that unit lost N28.2 billion at the operating level.
Exploration and production earned an operating profit of N183.5 billion on N553.6 billion of revenue.
Oando’s real problem sits below operating profit. Net finance costs reached N235.2 billion, including N218.6 billion of interest on bank loans, compared with net finance income of N128 billion a year earlier. Bank interest alone was 1.25 times gross profit, on MoneyCentral calculations.
Oando’s operating profit covered net finance costs only 0.68 times. A cover below one means operating earnings did not pay for the interest bill. Seplat covered its net finance costs 9.78 times.
Balance Sheet Strain
Oando’s total liabilities of N5.56 trillion exceed its total assets of N5.04 trillion. That leaves shareholders’ funds negative at N512.6 billion, which is why its debt-to-equity ratio is negative.
Its current assets of N1.07 trillion cover only a quarter of the N4.28 trillion in current liabilities. Current borrowings alone are N1.62 trillion, or 75% of total debt. Cash fell 60% in nine months to N175.9 billion, and the current ratio was weaker than the 0.44 at end-2025, on MoneyCentral calculations.
Seplat’s debt to equity fell to 0.43 from about 0.55 at end-2025, as non-current borrowings dropped to N960.3 billion from N1.34 trillion.
Aradel’s ratio also improved, to 0.77 from 0.93. The company repaid $263.9 million of debt and moved to net cash of $396.3 million, CardinalStone Research said in its November 18 note.
Oando’s High Acquisition Debt and Low Oil Production vs Peers
Oando’s borrowings trace back to two deals:
-
NAOC: it bought 100% of Nigerian Agip Oil Co. from Eni in 2024 for $783 million, including reimbursements.
-
ConocoPhillips: it bought ConocoPhillips’ Nigerian business in 2014.
The company is now paying down that debt. Total borrowings fell about 20% in naira terms from N2.70 trillion at end-2025, on MoneyCentral calculations.
Oil Output also rose 14% to 42,985 barrels of oil equivalent a day, according to its Oando NGX filings.
The Seplat and Aradel however produce far more. CardinalStone expects Seplat’s 2026 group output at 147,000 barrels of oil equivalent a day, and Aradel averaged 144,700 on an equity basis in the nine months to September 2026, according to the brokerage’s notes.
Bottom-Line
Oando made N159.7 billion of operating profit, but its debt costs took all of it and more and while valuation looks cheap it rests on weak earnings.
Oando closed at N34.50 on November 19, after rising as high as N38 last week, according to NGX data. That values the company at about N503 billion.
On annualised nine-month earnings after tax, the price-to-earnings ratio is about 3 times, on MoneyCentral calculations. However, those earnings depend on the tax credit, so the low multiple is less of a bargain than it looks and on a pretax basis, Oando lost money.
About N1.62 trillion of Oando debt is due within a year, against N175.9 billion of cash and a fall in oil prices from the current levels of about $88 to $96 a barrel would hit Oando hardest because its interest cover is thinnest.
The peers have different strengths:
-
Seplat has the cleanest balance sheet of the three. CardinalStone rates it HOLD with a target of N17,588.87, about 8% above its reference price of N16,241.90.
-
Aradel makes strong operating profits, but the earnout weighs on them. CardinalStone cut its target to N1,563.07 while keeping a BUY rating.
